1909-1926

Rugby League in Brisbane

The advent of professional rugby league in New South Wales saw many Queensland rugby players leaving for Sydney to play league. In 1908, the Queensland Rugby Union (QRU) banned its players from going to Sydney to play league, which resulted in disgruntled players forming the Queensland Amateur Rugby Football League (later renamed to the Queensland Rugby League). The new organisation was attacked by both the local press and the QRU for introducing professionalism, which they claimed would destroy the sport. The first official club competition commenced on Saturday 8th May 1909 with four Clubs namely North Brisbane, Toombul, Valleys and South Brisbane.

The league started the year by altering its name to the Queensland Amateur Rugby League (QARL) on 8th March, 1909. Expressions of interest were then sent by the league to numerous sporting organisations and clubs, which eventually resulted in four district teams based on electoral boundaries, accepting the challenge of playing the new football code. The four sides were North Brisbane (red and black), South Brisbane (sky blue), Toombul (red, white and blue), and Valley (royal blue).

To market the game, two weeks of double-header trial matches were staged free-of-charge at Davies Park in April 1909 with George Watson and Alf Faulkner respectively as referees, while the touch judges for both matches were A Vizer and A Tighe. Later fixtures were controlled by the Queensland Amateur Rugby League Referees’ Association which was formed around the same time – the Chairman being Mr W H ‘Bill’ Beattie. Members included were A Ambrose, M Bore, Buck Buchanan, Alf Faulkner, J Fihelly, G Gilles, A Tighe, A Vizer and George Watson.

The 1909 grand final, saw a section of the 1500 strong crowd being less than pleased with the performance of referee Jack Fihelly that day however, voicing their feelings throughout the match. However, the police were well represented to prevent any incident from occurring after the match.

John “Jack” Arthur Fihelly MLA (1882–1945)

1909 BRL Grand Final Referee
President of the QRL 1913-1915
and the father of the game in Queensland1

Jack Fihelly was an enthusiastic footballer. An aggressive forward, he represented Queensland against New South Wales in 1905-07, and in 1907 both Queensland and Australia against New Zealand. A founder of the Rugby League code in Queensland and a Queensland and Australia representative player, he was also assistant manager of the first Australian team to visit Britain in 1908-09. He became a referee later, officiating during the first war world. He was president of the Queensland Amateur Rugby Football League in 1914-16. Confident, ambitious and a protégé of Edward (Red Ted) Theodore2.

The Brisbane Rugby League was formed in 1922 due to objections between the Brisbane rugby league club and the Queensland Rugby League (QRL). A number of decisions from the 1918 ‘Ricketty Johnston Affair” and subsequent outcomes caused some disquiet. At the time, the BRL fixtures were controlled by QRL affiliated referees who were on individual signed contracts with the BRL. The formation of BRL ensured a major change where a six club three-grade senior competition was created, with the establishment of a BRL referees’ appointment committee. 3

Laurie Kearney officated a number of interstate games from 1919 to 1921. Source: The Daily Mail 18 July 1919.
Reg Leighton of Ipswich officiated the first BRL 1st Grade Grand Final. Source: The Telegraph 13 June 1924 p5.

The 1925 season ended in controversy when during the 1925 BRL grand final, a try by Coorparoo in the final minutes of the game was disallowed by the referee Alf Matzdorf, causing a narrow win to Brothers. The Coorparoo club lodged a protest, claiming the touch judge Stephenson was not in agreement 4. The protest was upheld by the BRL and agreed to a rematch. Subsequently Brothers appealed to the QRL. Brothers also attempted to censure the BRL chairman who was allegedly publicly supported the rematch 5.

The game ended up being replayed after much debate on the 12th September with Coorparoo winning by a point. The referee was Jack Roche who also acted as Chairman of the BRL during the censure motion.

At the end of the 1925 season, Edward James “Ted” Hooper former Sydney 1st grade rugby union forward and the inaugural New South Wales Rugby League Referees’ Association president passed away after he volunteered his services to officiate a Brisbane v Ipswich Referees match which was held during half-time of the Queensland Firsts v New South Wales Firsts match on the 22nd August 1926. Ted collapsed whilst showering after this game, he was aged 55 6.

A mid-season dispute occurred during the 1926 season, where the referees’ threaten to strike over QRL bonus payments to representative match referees. However, a bigger dispute between the BRL and QRL over control of the metropolitan games occurred at the season’s end 7 started to emerge within the refereeing ranks. As talks deteriorated, the BRL approached a number of the rugby league referees to change their name to the Brisbane Rugby League Referees’ Association (BRLRA) and to affiliate with the BRL as its governing body. After advertising for new members, a special meeting of the members was held at Gilbert Chambers in Queen Street on Monday 20 September 1926.

On 8 Monday November 1926, a meeting of the Queensland Rugby League Referees’ Association discussed the dispute between the Queensland Rugby League and the BRL8. A delegate from each of the leagues attended and submitted their views on the dispute. The dispute was centred on which league controlled the Brisbane referees, especially over the allocation and payments of the new metropolitan leagues being played at the time. A motion moved by J Allen and seconded by Mr. Sturgess, supported the BRL view. The motion was ruled out of order by the chair as the association was the Queensland Rugby League Referees’ Association. The meeting was then adjourned. Following the meeting, another meeting was hurried called with Jack Quinlan being voted to the chair. On the motion of M O’Connor seconded by E. Crawford, a Brisbane Rugby League Referees’ Association Was formed. Jack Quinlan was appointed president and R. Muir as secretary (pro tern), later by TJ Laws. The meeting adjourned until the following Monday when a constitution will be drafted. The constitution was ready by March 1927.

The photograph below shows the 1926 Queensland Rugby League Referees’ Association, just prior to the formation of the association.

Back row left to right – W Tuckett, EA Crawford, A Matzdorf, S Russell, M Ahlberg, J Brady.
Second row – JE Court, TJ Laws (international), C Kilpatrick, R Muir, TI Fry (B.A.), T Freeze, WE Stock.
Sitting – C Sturgess, F Smith, M O’Connor (vice-president), EA Cludwick (president), EJ Goodwill (international, hon, secretary and Q.R.L. life member), P Cutluck, JE Jones.
Source: The Telegraph 4th September 1926 page 14.

References

  1. Max Howell, 2008. The Centenary of the Greatest Game Under the Sun – One Hundred Years of Rugby League in Queensland. p44. Celebrity Books, Indooroopilly.
  2. Betty Crouchley, 1981. Fihelly, John Arthur (1882–1945). Webpage accessed January 2015.
  3. Mike Higgison, date unknown. QRL History The 1920s – the first golden era”. Webpage accessed January 2015.
  4. Anon, 1925. Rugby League, Coorparoo Enters Protest. p8. Daily Standard 15 July 1926
  5. Anon, 1925. Rugby League, BRL’s Confidence in Chairman. p4. Daily Standard 6 August 1925
  6. Anon, 1925. Pioneer Officer Dies Under Shower. p9. Daily Standard 24 August 1925
  7. Anon, 1926. Rugby League Split Brisbane Opposes Change. p3. The Telegraph 15 October 1926
  8. Anon, 1926. Football Dispute Attitude of Referees New Association Formed. p16. The Telegraph 9 November 1926

Back to History Page

Home of the biggest referee association in the world!